Another Disputed Discovery: Are Negatives Really by Ansel Adams?

Ten years ago a Fresno, California, man named Rick Norsigian made a garage sale find of sixty-five negatives which he came to believe were by the famous American photographer Ansel Adams.  Late last month, at a Beverly Hills press conference, he announced experts who had studied the writing on the negative sleeves had identified the hand as that of Adam’s wife — adding considerable weight to Norsigian’s claim.  The estimated value of the negatives if authentic:  $200 million.

But an 87 year-old Oakland woman named Marion Walton, who just happened to have some prints very similar to Norsigian’s in her home and saw a clip of the Norsigian press conference on television, almost immediately disputed the claim.  She thinks the photos were taken by her Uncle Earl.

Today, KTVU TV in Oakland reports that another panel of experts who have examined and compared the Norsigian plates with Ms. Walton’s prints agrees that indeed Uncle Earl — Earl Brooks, who back in the 1920s apparently did a lot of picture-taking in one of Adams’ favorite haunts, Yosemite — was the artist, not Adams.

Norsigian will probably continue to argue his case, but I think at this point we can at least score one for Uncle Earl.

If you’re interested, Greensboro Public Library has a number of books on or by Ansel Adams.  These include:  America’s Wilderness:  The Photographs of Ansel Adams, with the writings of John Muir, edited by Elaine M. Bucher; Ansel Adams:  America’s Photographer; A Biography for Young People by Beverly Gherman (juvenile); Ansel Adams:  A Biography by Mary Street Alinder; Ansel Adams:  Classic Images by James Alinder and John Szarkowski; Ansel Adams:  Letters and Images, 1916-1984, by Ansel Adams, edited by Mary Street Alinder and Andrea Gray Stillman; foreword by Wallace Stegner; Ansel Adams, An Autobiography, with Mary Street Alinder; and Ansel Adams, Our National Parks by Ansel Adams, edited by William A. Turnage and Andrea G. Stillman.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: